Tips for Avoiding Garage Sale Scams

You probably already know that the less stuff you move, the less you pay for your move. So, it's always a good idea to filter through everything and get rid of the stuff you don't need.  It's also a great idea to have a moving sale and sell the stuff you don't need— then put the money towards your moving cost.

If that's your plan, great. It's lots of work, but worth it (I think).

Before you hit the carport with your little yellow price stickers and the cash box— or fanny pack (because that's what's recommended), beware because garage sale scams are a possibility.  We did a little research, and these are some common garage sale scams we found:

The "distraction" scam:
Thieves will sometimes use a child or an adult accomplice to distract you while they pocket your items. The "accomplice" may ask you a question or pull you to another location where your back is to the thief.  The solution: Have several workers manning the sale. 

The "change" scam:
When paying you, the thief will hand you a $10, distract you, then tell you they handed you a $20.  The solution: Keep the bill in sight while you're getting their change, and repeat the amount they gave you immediately (say something like "out of $10").

The "tag switching" scam:
This is another garage sale scam that could be placed under the "distraction" heading. Rather than blatantly steal, they distract you, then switch price tags with another lower priced item.  The solution: Again, have several workers working the sale.

The "customer adds it up" scam:
Although some people do this to try to be helpful, scammers do it too.  They'll add the price tags for you and tell you how much it is…lowering your tagged price. The solution: Tell them you appreciate the help, but you are selling items for friends/family and you need to keep the price stickers.  This will allow you to calculate the price.

The "empty box" scam:
To be less obvious, the thief will empty a box (or CD case etc.), pocket the item, and leave the box. The solution: once again, having extra help walking around can divert thieves with this plan. 

  • Tips for garage sale safety:
  • Never work the sale alone.
  • Instead of a cash box, use a fanny pack. 
  • Have one designated cashier.
  • Don't keep large amounts of cash in sight— empty it and put it in the house.
  • If someone gives you a large bill ($100) for a small item, tell them you'll gladly hold the item while they get change.
  • Lock all other doors and windows so there is no access to your house.
  • Never let garage sale customers inside your home (even if they ask to try on clothes).
  • Accept cash only— no personal checks.